An Ethical Argument

    There are plenty of ethical arguments to take a look at in a field with as large of an impact as mechanical engineering. Many times mechanical engineers have to make a decision which will have a direct impact on people's lives and the environment either directly or indirectly. The two sides of most of these arguments can be summarized money versus safety.  The fact that there even has to be this kind of choice is that engineers have to work for businesses, and as such there has to be a profit or that business won' t around very long.

    Contrary to what is generally thought of people, the average person wants everyone to be as safe as possible. This is the same with mechanical engineers. If it were up to them, everything they ever designed would be made with the best materials available and would probably be a little overkill just to make sure it never even had a chance of breaking.

    

    On the opposite side of this spectrum, the average person also wants to make the most money for any given product they sell. This is the same for mechanical engineers. They also would like the greatest amount of money for each product they design. As such they would like every product they are involved with to have the greatest possible margin. This means minimizing costs. In order to do this, the mechanical engineer would want to have the product made from the cheapest material that barely gets the job done while barely not breaking. 

Click for source

    As you can see there is a contradiction within every choice that a mechanical engineer has to make. Even if they are not the one with the final say, they have to show that they are not being a greedy mechanical engineer who is skimming by on safety just to maximize profits, but also that they are not being an overly-cautious mechanical engineer who is over spending way too much on materials just to make sure that the product won't break.  

    These two sides of a mechanical are balanced out by factors of safety. These are used to act as buffers in almost every calculation computer. The higher the factor of safety the more cautious the engineer is being. The lower the factor of safety the more frugal the engineer is being. Normally the factor of safety for a project or calculation is not left to the engineer performing the calculation. It is usually left to some form of management since it is a very important decision. 

     If ever something actually does go wrong in a product, everything will get reviewed. Therefore the engineer has to be able to back up all of his/her choices in design with logical calculations. They have to be able to say that while they were paying attention to cost, they also left a reasonable margin of safety by using a factor of safety in their calculations.  Therefore the problem in the product is coming from somewhere else, and they should not be sued for some form of negligence that resulted in loss of property or even a death.